| Date | Location | Result | |
| 2/24/00 | Bristol, Va. - Virginia High | Milligan 76, Covenant 72 | Box score |
| 2/22/00 | Covenant 80, Alice Lloyd 77 | Box score | |
| 2/18/00 | Montreat College 76, Covenant 70 | Box score | |
| 2/15/00 | Tennessee Wesleyan 62, Covenant 54 | Box score | |
| 2/12/00 | Alice Lloyd 73, Covenant 69 | Box score | |
| 2/11/00 | Bluefield 102, Covenant 84 | Box score | |
| 2/8/00 | Tennessee Temple Univeristy 91, Covenant 82 | Box score | |
| 2/5/00 | Virginia Intermont 86, Covenant 70 | Box score | |
| 1/29/00 | Montreat College 92, Covenant 76 | Box score | |
| 1/25/00 | Bryan College 82, Covenant 64 | Box score | |
| 1/21/00 | Alice Lloyd 89, Covenant 78 | Box score | |
| 1/18/00 | Tennessee Wesleyan 75, Covenant 62 | Box score | |
| 1/15/00 | Milligan 80, Covenant 53 | Box score | |
| 1/14/00 | King College 66, Covenant 54 | Box score | |
| 1/8/00 | Wheaton College 90, Covenant 83 | Box score | |
| 1/7/00 | UVA-Wise 79, Covenant 60 | Box score | |
| 1/4/00 | Methodist University 94, Covenant 57 | Box score | |
| 12/29/99 | Liberty University 82, Covenant 51 | Box score | |
| 12/10/99 | Covenant 88, Tennessee Temple Univeristy 82 | Box score | |
| 12/7/99 | Milligan 91, Covenant 90 | Box score | |
| 12/1/99 | Fisk University 88, Covenant 59 | Box score | |
| 11/27/99 | Covenant 76, Wesley 54 | Box score | |
| 11/26/99 | Belhaven College 76, Covenant 67 | Box score | |
| 11/23/99 | Covenant 72, King College 68 | Box score | |
| 11/20/99 | Virginia Intermont 94, Covenant 85 | Box score | |
| 11/19/99 | Wise, Va. | UVA-Wise 84, Covenant 59 | Box score |
| 11/16/99 | Lookout Moutnain, Ga. | Bryan College 76, Covenant 70 | Box score |
| 11/13/99 | Lookout Moutnain, Ga. | Covenant 82, Bluefield 79 | Box score |
| 11/11/99 | Cleveland, Tenn. | Lee University (Tenn.) 87, Covenant 85 | Box score |
| unknown | at Thomas | Thomas (Ga.) 139, Covenant 88 | Box score |